Loading...
Title : Is California's New Ban on For-Profit Charters a Charade or a Step in the Right Direction? Education Law Prof Blog
link : Is California's New Ban on For-Profit Charters a Charade or a Step in the Right Direction? Education Law Prof Blog
Is California's New Ban on For-Profit Charters a Charade or a Step in the Right Direction? Education Law Prof Blog
Education Law Prof BlogIs California's New Ban on For-Profit Charters a Charade or a Step in the Right Direction?
My recent post on California's new charter school bill may have been too quick to lavish praise on the state for banning for-profit groups from managing charters. For-profit charter operators are definitely a problem. Allowing them is the equivalent of laying out a welcome sign to exploitation and legalized corruption. For-profit operators can, for instance, entering into self-serving lease and contract agreements. They can do things that would land public school officials in jail, but which are relatively common among charter school operators. Barring open corruption is a big deal, at least, symbolically. And California does have some for-profit operators that will have to change their status and practices in the future for those charters to move forward.
But whether this new ban on for-profit charter operators changes the fundamental reality of what is occurring in most charter schools in California is a different question. And, if it does not change the industry overall, the symbolic victory of this new law may make it harder to actually go after less obvious problems in the future. The public might simply think the state has cleaned the sector cleaned up and, thus, be more forgiving of other questionable charter expansions in the future.
As I emphasized in my recent post,
there is still more to be done to ensure that non-profit charters are acting like non-profits. The California law stops charters from acting purely as shell companies for outside entities, but they don't stop non-profit charters from paying their upper level staff and management unreasonably high salaries while paying their teachers unreasonably low ones. They also don't stop non-profit charters from entering into unreasonable leases. As Tom Kelley has shown, exorbitant leases appear to be one of the biggest profit-taking mechanisms. No non-profit acting in its and its students' own best interests would every enter into some of these lease agreements. California's new statute prohibits for-profit management, but it does not prohibit lease deals that are not on the up-and-up. To be clear, the point of leasing out one's land is to make money. So leases that send profits to landlords are not inherently problematic. but California should not think its job is done with this statute. It still needs to exercise enough oversight to ferret out problematic contracts and leases and ensure that state money is spent on students.
Carol Burris's new essay in the Washington Post's Answer sheet digs deeper into the facts and shows that this new bill may not be that big of a deal at all. First, "Only 34 of California’s approximately 1,200 charter schools are Continue reading: Education Law Prof Blog
thus Article Is California's New Ban on For-Profit Charters a Charade or a Step in the Right Direction? Education Law Prof Blog
that is all articles Is California's New Ban on For-Profit Charters a Charade or a Step in the Right Direction? Education Law Prof Blog This time, hopefully can provide benefits to all of you. Okay, see you in another article posting.
You now read the article Is California's New Ban on For-Profit Charters a Charade or a Step in the Right Direction? Education Law Prof Blog with the link address https://onechildsmart.blogspot.com/2018/09/is-californias-new-ban-on-for-profit.html
0 Response to "Is California's New Ban on For-Profit Charters a Charade or a Step in the Right Direction? Education Law Prof Blog"
Post a Comment