Loading...

CURMUDGUCATION: Creating More Defective Children PLUS When Local Control Turns Toxic

Loading...
CURMUDGUCATION: Creating More Defective Children PLUS When Local Control Turns Toxic - Hallo friend SMART KIDS, In the article you read this time with the title CURMUDGUCATION: Creating More Defective Children PLUS When Local Control Turns Toxic, we have prepared well for this article you read and download the information therein. hopefully fill posts Article baby, Article care, Article education, Article recipes, we write this you can understand. Well, happy reading.

Title : CURMUDGUCATION: Creating More Defective Children PLUS When Local Control Turns Toxic
link : CURMUDGUCATION: Creating More Defective Children PLUS When Local Control Turns Toxic

see also


CURMUDGUCATION: Creating More Defective Children PLUS When Local Control Turns Toxic

CURMUDGUCATION: Creating More Defective Children

Creating More Defective Children


This has always been a dangerous side effect of educational certainty. If I'm absolutely certain that my program is awesome, my pedagogy is flawless, my materials are on point, and classroom is just generally perfect-- and yet some students are not learning-- well, there's only one possible explanation. The student must be defective.

The defect effect appears to be cropping up in a new place. As reported in EdWeek, a new report published in the New England Journal of Medicine suggests that children who turn five the month before kindergarten starts are, as a group, being over-diagnosed with ADHD.

"Our findings suggest the possibility that large numbers of kids are being over-diagnosed and overtreated for ADHD because they happen to be relatively immature compared to their older classmates in the early years of elementary school," said study author Timothy Layton, and assistant professor of health care policy at Harvard Medical School.

Relative immaturity is one factor to consider here. But why would this start cropping up in recent years; why wouldn't the relative immaturity of August babies be so well-known and widely recognized from the last century of schooling that schools would simply set an earlier cut-off date? In Pennsylvania, 78% of school districts make the cut-off September 1. There is some anecdotal reporting of increased redshirting but the study above suggests that perhaps there should be more.

Are we looking at a correction to bad education policy being made at the grassroots level.

In other words, if kindergarten is the new first grade, are more parents concluding that 6 is the new CONTINUE READING: 
CURMUDGUCATION: Creating More Defective Children

When Local Control Turns Toxic



I am a fan of local control for school districts, but I'm not going to pretend that under the wrong circumstances it won't produce some terrible results.

EdBuild has just issued a report on a troubling phenomenon-- the secession of wealthy communities from larger school districts. This issue has been reported on before, but this is a report that collects instances of attempts across the nation.

EdBuild is not an organization that I'd ordinarily be promoting. Their reform credentials are deep, from Founder/CEO Rebecca Sibilia who used to be the COO of StudentsFirst to a board headed by Derrell Bradford of NYCAN (among other groups). They do have some actual teachers like Nate Bowling on their board of advisors, but mostly this is another group that runs deep with people without actual experience in education, and most of their policy positions are heavily school choicey.

But neither education experience or complex methodology is needed to collect this kind of data, and the results are not great. Since 2000, 128 communities have tried to secede from their school districts, and 74 have been successful.

A large chunk of those are not hard to explain. The map shows a huge group of seceding districts in Maine. For about a decade, Maine put big pressure on its districts to consolidate, with a plan to turn almost 300 school districts into 26. There were severe financial penalties for keeping your own district, until Governor LaPage eliminated the penalties; at that point, many districts headed for the door. The many secession fights in Maine represent an attempt by districts to maintain their original shape, not surprising in a state that is largely rural and it can take 90 minutes to travel a distance that is 30 miles as the crow flies. The state of Maine accounts for a full half of the 74 seceding districts and so allows EdBuild to inflate their total numbers.

Front of the big beautiful HS Collierville built its students,
once it got them out of Shelby County Schools
Still, the uninflated numbers and the stories that go with them are still pretty troubling. In Louisiana, Tennessee and Alabama, what we see are severe examples of school district gerrymandering, and the story, over and over, is of rich white folks trying to get themselves a district that doesn't include so many of those poor Black folks. The Shelby County school districts are a fine example of white flight, district secession, and the hoarding of resources so that wealthy folks don't have to spend tax dollars on Those People's Children.

I presume that this phenomenon can be used to argue that choice has to be implemented to rescue 
 CONTINUE READING: When Local Control Turns Toxic






thus Article CURMUDGUCATION: Creating More Defective Children PLUS When Local Control Turns Toxic

that is all articles CURMUDGUCATION: Creating More Defective Children PLUS When Local Control Turns Toxic This time, hopefully can provide benefits to all of you. Okay, see you in another article posting.

You now read the article CURMUDGUCATION: Creating More Defective Children PLUS When Local Control Turns Toxic with the link address https://onechildsmart.blogspot.com/2019/04/curmudgucation-creating-more-defective.html

Subscribe to receive free email updates:

0 Response to "CURMUDGUCATION: Creating More Defective Children PLUS When Local Control Turns Toxic"

Post a Comment

Loading...